High Court Dismisses Commercial Tenancy Appeal with RM10,000 Costs — Another Victory for JY Ko Advocates & Solicitors

Kuala Lumpur | November 2026 | Civil Appeals, Commercial Tenancy Disputes & Property Litigation
We are pleased to announce another successful litigation outcome for JY Ko Advocates & Solicitors, following the Kuala Lumpur High Court’s dismissal of an appeal brought against our client in a commercial tenancy dispute.
In Kuala Lumpur High Court Civil Appeal No. WA-12BNCvC-29-03/2026, the High Court had on 17th November 2026 dismissed the Appellant’s appeal and awarded RM10,000 in costs in favour of our client, the Respondent.
Our firm represented the Respondent in defending the appeal, which arose from an earlier decision of the Kuala Lumpur Sessions Court dismissing an Originating Summons (Saman Pemula) concerning alleged unlawful denial of access to commercial premises.
The Sessions Court had previously dismissed the Appellant’s application on 25 February 2026 with costs of RM1,500. The High Court’s dismissal of the appeal leaves that decision undisturbed.
The dispute raised important issues concerning commercial tenancy agreements, locus standi, privity of contract, alleged unlawful eviction, estoppel, mandatory injunctions and Section 7 of the Specific Relief Act 1950.
Background: A Commercial Tenancy Dispute in Kuala Lumpur
The dispute concerned a commercial office unit at Sunway Velocity Designer Office, Kuala Lumpur.
Our client, the property owner, had entered into a tenancy agreement dated 20 March 2022 with Fast Strike Resources & Consultancy Sdn. Bhd. (FSRC).
The tenancy was subsequently extended until 20 September 2025.
However, the company that commenced legal proceedings against our client was not FSRC. Instead, the proceedings were brought by Paradise Agriculture International Sdn. Bhd., a separate company incorporated on 3 February 2025.
Paradise Agriculture maintained that it had occupied the premises, conducted business operations there and made rental payments which had been accepted by our client.
It further alleged that our client had unlawfully locked the premises and prevented access to retrieve its business belongings.
Our client’s position was that the contractual tenancy existed with FSRC, not Paradise Agriculture. Our client also relied on the rental defaults, notices issued to FSRC, subsequent recovery of possession and the letting of the premises to another tenant.
These competing positions ultimately led to litigation before the Sessions Court and a subsequent appeal to the High Court.
What Did Paradise Agriculture Seek from the Court?
Paradise Agriculture commenced proceedings by way of an Originating Summons dated 14 November 2025.
Among the reliefs sought were:
- A declaration that our client’s alleged act of locking or restricting access to the premises was unlawful.
- A mandatory injunction compelling our client to permit access to retrieve the company’s belongings.
- An order under Section 7 of the Specific Relief Act 1950 for the return of belongings allegedly remaining in the premises.
- Costs and further relief deemed appropriate by the Court.
The Appellant’s case was not simply a claim for unpaid money or a conventional action to enforce a tenancy agreement.
It centred on whether a company that was not named as a tenant under the written tenancy agreement could establish sufficient legal rights to challenge the property owner’s actions and obtain the requested court orders.
The Sessions Court Dismissed the Originating Summons
On 25 February 2026, the Kuala Lumpur Sessions Court dismissed Paradise Agriculture’s Originating Summons with costs of RM1,500.
The Sessions Court’s written grounds addressed several material legal issues.
1. Locus Standi and Privity of Contract
A fundamental issue was whether Paradise Agriculture possessed the necessary legal standing to maintain its proceedings against our client.
The written tenancy agreement had been entered into between our client and FSRC. Paradise Agriculture was not a contracting party.
Our case emphasised the distinction between a company physically using premises and a company possessing an enforceable contractual or other legal entitlement to occupy them.
The Sessions Court accepted that Paradise Agriculture had not established the tenancy rights which it asserted against our client.
2. Does Acceptance of Rental Payments Create a Tenancy?
Another issue concerned the Appellant’s reliance on rental payments and communications with our client.
Paradise Agriculture argued that the acceptance of payments supported its position that it had been recognised as an occupier or tenant.
We disputed that interpretation.
A payment originating from a particular company’s bank account does not, by itself, establish that the company has become the contractual tenant. The surrounding arrangements, conduct, representations and any agreement between the relevant parties must be considered.
The Sessions Court rejected the Appellant’s contention that the circumstances established a new tenancy relationship through estoppel by conduct.
3. Lawful Occupation and Section 7 of the Specific Relief Act 1950
The proceedings also raised questions concerning statutory protection against recovery of possession without court proceedings.
Paradise Agriculture alleged that our client had resorted to unlawful self-help by restricting access to the premises.
Our client’s defence disputed the Appellant’s claimed status as a lawful occupier and its entitlement to the particular statutory protection relied upon.
The Sessions Court rejected the Appellant’s claim on the facts and legal arguments before it.
Importantly, disputes involving alleged lockouts and recovery of possession must be assessed according to the applicable statutory provisions and the specific circumstances. A property owner’s contractual rights do not automatically dispense with legal requirements governing possession.
4. Whether the Relief Had Become Academic
The Court also considered the practical consequences of the relief sought.
Our client had recovered possession of the premises in October 2025, and the premises were subsequently rented to a new tenant from 1 November 2025.
The Respondent’s case was that the belongings alleged by Paradise Agriculture were no longer in the premises and that the mandatory injunction sought would no longer serve its original practical purpose.
The Sessions Court accepted the argument that the principal relief had become academic, taking into account the changed circumstances and the interests of the new tenant.
Paradise Agriculture Appealed to the Kuala Lumpur High Court
Dissatisfied with the Sessions Court’s decision, Paradise Agriculture brought an appeal before the Kuala Lumpur High Court.
The appeal challenged the Sessions Court’s treatment of several issues, including locus standi, lawful occupation, estoppel, the allegation of unlawful self-help and the finding that the proceedings had become academic.
We defended the Sessions Court’s decision on behalf of our client.
Our submissions addressed the Appellant’s grounds of appeal, the relevant contractual arrangements, the affidavit evidence, the applicable principles of Malaysian law and the circumstances in which an appellate court should interfere with a lower court’s findings.
We also maintained that the particular mandatory relief sought by the Appellant had to be assessed in light of the subsequent occupation of the premises by a third party.
High Court Decision: Appeal Dismissed with RM10,000 Costs
The Kuala Lumpur High Court dismissed Paradise Agriculture International Sdn. Bhd.’s appeal and ordered costs of RM10,000 in favour of the Respondent.
This was a successful outcome for our client, who had defended the original proceedings and subsequently faced a challenge to the Sessions Court’s decision.
The High Court’s dismissal of the appeal means that the Sessions Court’s dismissal of the Originating Summons remains undisturbed.
The RM10,000 costs order in the appeal is separate from the RM1,500 costs previously ordered by the Sessions Court.
For our firm, this outcome represents another successful defence of our client’s interests in contested civil and commercial litigation.
What Can Landlords, Tenants and Businesses Learn from This Case?
This dispute illustrates several important practical considerations for commercial property owners, corporate tenants and businesses operating from rented premises.
A Written Tenancy Agreement Identifies the Contractual Parties
Where commercial premises are used by related companies, affiliated businesses or third-party operators, it is important to distinguish between the contractual tenant and the entity actually using the premises.
A company should not assume that it has automatically acquired another company’s tenancy rights merely because it conducts business at the property.
Any assignment, replacement tenancy, subletting arrangement or permission to occupy should be properly documented.
Rental Payments Must Be Considered in Context
Accepting rental payments from a company that is not named in the tenancy agreement may create evidential questions.
However, payment alone does not necessarily establish that a new tenancy has been created.
The parties’ intentions, communications, conduct and contractual arrangements may all be relevant.
Property Owners Must Exercise Care When Recovering Possession
Commercial landlords should carefully consider the legal requirements governing termination, possession and eviction.
Alleged lockouts, changes of locks and removal of belongings can give rise to separate disputes even where rental arrears exist.
Appropriate legal procedures should be considered before taking action that interferes with occupation.
The Relief Sought Must Remain Legally and Practically Appropriate
Where court proceedings seek access to premises or the return of specific belongings, subsequent events may affect whether the requested orders can still be granted effectively.
The existence of a new tenant, the location of disputed property and the precise relief pleaded may become material to the proceedings.
Frequently Asked Questions About Commercial Tenancy Disputes in Malaysia
Can a company claim tenancy rights if its name is not in the tenancy agreement?
A company that is not named in a tenancy agreement does not automatically acquire the contractual tenant’s rights merely by using the premises or making payments. Whether it has an independent contractual, statutory or other legally enforceable right depends on the circumstances and evidence.
Does paying rent automatically make a company the lawful tenant?
No. Rental payments alone do not necessarily establish a landlord-and-tenant relationship. The parties’ agreements, conduct and intentions must be examined.
Can a landlord lock a tenant out of commercial premises in Malaysia?
A landlord’s ability to recover possession is subject to applicable contractual and statutory requirements, including the Specific Relief Act 1950
re relevant. Landlords should obtain legal advice before taking steps to exclude an occupier or recover possession without court proceedings.
Can a party seek a mandatory injunction to retrieve belongings from rented premises?
A mandatory injunction may be available where the applicable legal requirements are satisfied. The claimant must establish an appropriate legal basis for the relief sought, supported by evidence. The Court will also consider the practicality and consequences of making the order.
Can the High Court dismiss an appeal from the Sessions Court?
Yes. The High Court may dismiss a civil appeal where the appellant fails to establish grounds warranting appellate intervention. In this case, the High Court dismissed Paradise Agriculture’s appeal with RM10,000 costs.
Civil Appeal and Commercial Tenancy Lawyers in Kuala Lumpur
At JY Ko Advocates & Solicitors, we represent landlords, property owners, companies, directors and individuals in civil and commercial disputes, including contested tenancy proceedings and appeals.
Our litigation practice includes disputes involving contractual rights, unpaid rent, recovery of vacant possession, wrongful termination, alleged unlawful eviction, injunctions and appellate proceedings.
We also accept instructions from other law firms requiring representation or counsel in contested civil hearings and appeals.
Readers seeking further information may refer to our guides on civil appeals in Malaysia, tenancy disputes in Malaysia and commercial property litigation.
If you are involved in a commercial tenancy dispute or need legal representation to defend an appeal, you may contact JY Ko Advocates & Solicitors to discuss the relevant facts, evidence and available legal options.
JY Ko Advocates & Solicitors
Civil & Commercial Litigation Lawyers
Kuala Lumpur
Website: https://jykolaw.com
Case reference: Paradise Agriculture International Sdn. Bhd. v Tan Teik Jee, Kuala Lumpur High Court Civil Appeal No. WA-12BNCvC-29-03/2026. The discussion of the Sessions Court’s reasoning and the parties’ appellate arguments should not be treated as a statement of the High Court’s unprovided grounds of decision. Each dispute depends on its facts and applicable law.
Written on 21st November 2026 (Saturday)
Contact JY Ko Advocates & Solicitors to make an appointment today!

🌐 Call us: +6017.6965.966 (Call / WhatsApp)
📩 Email Us: nick@jykolaw.com
Disclaimer: The above proposition is subject to actual facts and circumstances and shall never be referred as the actual law without seeking legal advice. Consult us for more information!
